Homily for the Solemnity of Christ the King 2026
Readings: Ezekiel 34:11-12,15-17; Psalm 23; 1 1 Corinthians 15:20-26,28; Matthew 25:31-46
Listen at soundcloud.com
This past week, I think Todd Greenberg, the CEO of Cricket Australia, gave us all a lesson in one of the big things wrong with our world. Before Cam Bancroft spilt the beans, Mr Greenberg was adamant that there was no need for an inquiry. Why? Because there is just no such thing as truth.
This is the way Greenberg put it: ‘I think they can both be true (Khawaja and Cummins) because it’s their version of events. Their version of events is their truth. I’m not here to tell someone what they should believe. Nor should they tell me what I should believe. My version of events might be different to yours. They can be true to you and to me. That’s the difficulty. This is their version of events (Khawaja and Warner). It’s not for me to disrespect their view. Equally, when Pat speaks, I have to accept their version of events because I wasn’t there. I wasn’t part of it and I didn’t see it. I can only accept different versions of the truth. It’s their versions at that particular moment in time.’[1]
I have no interest in taking sides in an 8 year old cricket dispute. It’s been a tragedy for everyone involved. But let’s not settle on the mantra that there is no such thing as truth, and that everyone can believe their own version of the truth, regardless of the evidence.
Pope John Paul II once wrote: ‘Once the idea of a universal truth about the good, knowable by human reason, is lost, inevitably the notion of conscience also changes.’[2] Later, Pope Francis wrote: ‘A society is noble and decent, not least for its support of the pursuit of truth and its adherence to the most basic of truths.’[3]
In his encyclical Magnifica Humanitas, Pope Leo writes: ‘The search for truth is an essential element of democracy, which is itself a means of contributing to the common good. When questions about what is true lose their appeal, and a pragmatism takes hold that is content with what appears useful or effective, then democratic life is weakened.’[4]
This week’s cricket controversy is about more than cricket. It confronts us with the reality that many actors in the contemporary public square are convinced that there is no such thing as truth.
There is. And it matters.
In today’s gospel we come to Matthew’s great crescendo in Chapter 25. We have heard a series of parables about the kingdom of heaven. Now we come to the description of the last judgement.
After his retirement as Governor-General, Sir William Deane agreed to be interviewed about his faith on the ABC Encounter program. He told the interviewer Bill Bunbury: ‘More and more the whole of Christianity … for me comes down to Chapter 25 of St Matthew’s Gospel: I was hungry and he gave me food; I was thirsty, he gave me drink; I was without a home and he took me in … I was in prison and you came to me. That, if you think about the context of St Matthew’s Gospel, is the whole touchstone by which according to Christian belief, one’s life ultimately tends to be assessed, or stands to be assessed.’[5]
Deane’s respect for people of all faiths and none was always exemplary. A week after this interview, Deane spoke at the opening of the Chapel for the Australian Centre for Christianity and Culture. He commenced his remarks: ‘Forever there was God: the spirit and the source of life. Then there was creation and time began: with its story of matter, of our universe and of human beings inhabiting our world, including, throughout all the millennia of the Dreamtime, this ancient Continent.’ He then traced his vision of a Universal Christian Church:
‘When Christianity finally came here, it was accompanied – and betrayed – by the dispossession and oppression of the Indigenous peoples based upon the doctrine of terra nullius’s cruel untruth that their ancestral lands had been uninhabited. It was also weakened by divisive interdenominational rivalries and intolerance. While countless good – and sometimes great – men and women of vision and action achieved extraordinary things for the various Christian churches, it is only in very recent times that the yearning among Christians everywhere for the fellowship of common witness has found concrete expression and that the heightened perception of a Universal Christian Church has largely stilled the divisiveness of past internal bitterness and intolerance.’
Deane then proclaimed that the fundamental truth of Matthew Chapter 25 ‘is shared by other great religions of the world’. He footnoted ‘Judaism’s recognition that I am my brother’s keeper and Islam’s “Golden Rule” and prescription of “true charity” to all in need.’ He said this fundamental truth ‘should guide our nation. For, surely, it is the measure of the worth of any true democracy such as ours’.
He concluded: ‘Finally, to all our fellow Australians, Christian and non-Christian, we say: join us in our pilgrimage towards reconciliation, tolerance and justice and towards overcoming the divisions within our land. Let us talk together, walk together, strive together and achieve together. That way, we will also walk with God. Come with us.’
Sir William had proposed the toast to his old school for its 75th, 100th and 125th anniversaries. He said he would not be available for the 150th. When he was proposing the most recent toast, he recalled how he had consulted one of his old teachers Brother Ligouri about what he should say for the first toast back in 1956:
‘After some thought, Brother Ligouri suggested that my theme should be the spirit of (the school) which he saw as one of courage and no compromise. Courage in terms of standing up for what is right. No compromise in the sense that to compromise truth is to harbour falsehood and to compromise principle is to lose it. I followed his advice.’[6]
Let’s pray that we can all follow that advice, standing up for what is right, never compromising the truth, and living lives worthy of that final declaration:
‘For I was hungry and you gave me food,
I was thirsty and you gave me drink,
a stranger and you welcomed me,
naked and you clothed me,
ill and you cared for me,
in prison and you visited me.’
Fr Frank Brennan SJ AO, Adjunct Professor of Thomas More Law School at ACU and Adjunct Research Professor at the Australian Centre for Christianity and Culture, is a former Rector of Newman College, University of Melbourne, and CEO of Catholic Social Services Australia (CSSA). His latest books include Pope Francis: the Disruptive Pilgrims Guide (ATF Theology, 2025), and Equality, Reconciliation and Social Cohesion: The Inspiration of Sir William Deane (Connor Court, 2026).
[1] See https://www.nine.com.au/sport/cricket/news-cricket-australia-sandpapergate-forum-todd-greenberg-david-boon-usman-khawaja-david-warner-pat-cummins-20261118-p61fai.html
[2] Saint John Paul II, Encyclical Letter Veritatis Splendor (6 August 1993), 32 AAS 85 (1993), 1159.
[3] Francis, Encyclical Letter Fratelli Tutti (3 October 2020), 207 AAS 112 (2020), 1043.
[4] Leo XIV, Magnifica Humanitas, #134.
[5] Frank Brennan, Equality, Reconciliation and Social Cohesion: The Inspiration of Sir William Deane, Connor Court, 2026, 178-9.
[6] Ibid, xviii.
