Pope Leo and politics: Faggioli has penned the best book to date

By Michael Sean Winters, 18 November 2026
Pope Leo XIV during the General Audience at the Paul VI Hall on Wednesday 28 January 2026. Image: Vatican Media

Ever since Jesus of Nazareth told the Pharisees to render unto Caesar the things that are Caesar’s (Matthew 22:21), Christianity’s relationship with politics has been at once ambiguous and unavoidable. The Catholic Church has survived persecution by and integration within the Roman empire, the barbarian invasions and medieval fiefdoms, the rise of the nation-state and the Cold War, but each time, theologians have had their work cut out for them trying to decide what was Caesar’s and what was God’s.

In our time, everywhere one looks for some insight into the relationship of religion and politics, there are theological cul-de-sacs. Liberation theology is tired at best. Integralism has made a frightening comeback but remains as coarse and hoary as its 19th century iteration. Does anyone read Jürgen Moltmann anymore? The culture war model of Catholic political engagement has proven sterile but no one is sure how to replace it.

Then Pope Leo XIV emerged on the loggia of St. Peter’s and, for him, there is no escaping the challenge of figuring out how to engage the politics of our time while leading a church that is increasingly a global church. The first pope from a superpower. The first pope born in the United States. At a time when the U.S. is overturning what was best about the postwar international order. How is the pope to avoid the larger challenge of seeing all of his words and actions contrasted with those of President Donald Trump, a comparison that is entirely unhelpful to the pope?

To continue reading this article, click here.

With thanks to National Catholic Reporter and Michael Sean Winters, where this article originally appeared.

Read Daily
* indicates required

RELATED STORIES